Date Published: October 15, 2024, Last Updated on October 15, 2024 by Anthony Conte

Have you ever wondered whether a cork or a screw cap is the better choice for your favourite bottle of wine?

For years, the debate has swirled around which closure preserves the wine best, keeps flavours intact, and offers the most satisfying wine-drinking experience.

Whether you prefer the satisfying pop of a cork or the quick twist of a screw cap, let’s dive into the pros and cons to see which option might be best for your next bottle when you buy your wines online or in-store.

Cork screw wine closure

Cork wine closure

For centuries, natural cork has been the go-to choice for sealing wine bottles. This spongy material, harvested from the bark of cork oak trees, offers a unique blend of flexibility and durability.

Cork’s ability to allow a small amount of oxygen to interact with the wine plays a crucial role in the ageing process, helping to develop complex flavours over time. This natural process has made cork the preferred choice for fine wines throughout history.

However, cork, like any other wine seal, has its downsides. While it remains a popular choice, it’s important to weigh its advantages and limitations. Let’s explore the pros and cons of using cork as a wine seal.

Pros:

  1. Cork is a classic and traditional wine closure, adding a sense of ceremony and tradition when opening a bottle. It is often preferred for premium and age-worthy wines due to its historical reputation​
  2. Natural cork allows a tiny amount of oxygen to interact with the wine over time, which can enhance the wine’s complexity and flavour during ageing​
  3. Cork is a renewable and eco-friendly resource harvested from cork oak trees, making it one of the more environmentally sound options​

If you ever find yourself without a corkscrew, there are plenty of wine hacks to help you open your bottle effortlessly.

Cons:

  1. The biggest drawback is the risk of cork taint caused by the chemical compound TCA (trichloroanisole), which can spoil the wine’s flavour, giving it a musty or mouldy smell. It’s estimated that 3-10% of bottles sealed with cork are affected
  2. Because cork is a natural product, its quality can vary, affecting its seal and oxygen transfer rate. Over time, corks can also dry out and crumble, leading to potential wine spoilage​
  3. Corks can be up to three times more expensive than screw caps, which can add to the cost of the wine​

Screw cap wine seals

Screw caps as wine seals

Screw caps, often associated with cheaper wines in the past, have undergone a significant image makeover. They are now widely used across various wine styles and valued for their reliability and convenience.

Screw caps provide a consistent seal, ensuring that each bottle retains its intended flavours. This also makes it easier for wine enthusiasts to enjoy their favourite bottles without needing a corkscrew. Perfect for wines meant to be enjoyed young, screw caps help preserve the freshness and vibrancy of the wine.

Pros:

  1. Screw caps provide a tight seal and consistent performance, reducing the risk of spoilage and eliminating cork taint entirely​
  2. Easy to open without any tools, screw caps are a practical choice for casual wine drinkers
  3. Screw caps are ideal for wines meant to be consumed young, such as fresh whites and fruity reds, as they maintain freshness and fruit flavours by preventing oxygen from entering the bottle​(

Cons:

  1. The airtight nature of screw caps means that they don’t allow any oxygen to interact with the wine, which can hinder the development of more complex flavours over time. This makes them less suitable for wines that are meant to age​
  2. Despite growing acceptance, some consumers still perceive screw caps as a sign of lower-quality wine
  3. Made from aluminium, screw caps have a higher environmental footprint compared to natural cork, as aluminium extraction can be harmful to the environment​

Looking for great wine options without breaking the bank? Check out these wines under $25.

What’s Best for Your Wine?

So, which is better: cork or screw cap? The answer isn’t straightforward. It depends on the type of wine, how long you plan to store it, and your preferences.

Corks are ideal for wines that benefit from ageing, offering a traditional experience and the potential for complex flavours. Screw caps, on the other hand, provide consistency, convenience, and freshness, making them perfect for everyday wines.

Ultimately, both closures have their strengths, and the best choice is the one that aligns with your wine goals. Whether savouring a fine vintage or enjoying a casual bottle on a weeknight, the closure you choose should enhance your overall wine experience.

Find your perfect bottle

Looking to learn more about wine? Check out these most asked questions about wine and uncover everything you need to know.

Shop now at I Like Wine for various great options, and find the perfect bottle to complement your next meal or celebration.